criterion-sm dice-lg ea-starwars-lg instagram lucasfilm-lg motive-lg twitch you-tube
November Community Calendar

All Phase 1 Clone Legions Needs a SERIOUS Rework!!!

David1543
536 posts Member
edited October 18
This is how they look like right now:

0v7owpzsfkiy.png

Lame. Nothing but blue or red paint jobs, even though these are canon, they are all the same regardless of class and there's barely a distinction. That's not what the likes of the 501st deserves.

We need something like this:

rkb6stu7ejpb.jpg


dj6ajf1f2idm.jpg


The heavies and officers should have pauldrons and other items as well, each item should differ depending of the legion. Different legions should also have a distinction of color patterns.

Officers should look like something of this sort:

0g7ctvtj2h4l.png


Phase 1 just deserves better treatment, we need more variety, their current state is not good enough, some of you might be tired of Clone skins but every clone wars fan agree this is important.

I don't want to use the word "lazy" but the current state of the phase 1 Clone's is just disgraceful. They were rushed and no detail were put to them. Do you agree they need a few tweaks?



Post edited by David1543 on

Replies

  • Totally. Also bring back phase 1 - phase 2 clones depending on map
  • Actually I'd take the lame Episode 2 Phase 1 skins with dots.

    For my 2004 vibes.
  • This entire game needs a rework
  • Liz4rD
    1120 posts Member
    You dont want Luke to get real Luke's face, but instead you do want reworking the entire clone army.

    LOL, NO.
  • Liz4rD
    1120 posts Member
    @David1543
    cttzedjnn0b21.gif
    David1543 wrote: »
    This is how they look like right now:

    0v7owpzsfkiy.png

    Lame. Nothing but blue or red paint jobs, all the same regardless of class and there's barely a distinction. That's not what the likes of the 501st deserves.

    Because that's what they look like in canon.
    Phase 1 501st
    sng6ru1l80a3.png
    Phase 1 212th
    ubsxob2touwf.png
    Phase 1 327th
    kgdzezhb7pwk.png
    Phase 1 41st
    hskkae0f1zeg.png
    David1543 wrote: »
    We need something like this:

    gi7l06txdisy.png

    We have the one in the middle, the other 2 are non-canon.
    David1543 wrote: »
    u4zjrhge797y.jpg

    That's Fives and Echo, 2 clones with unique and distinctive markings that nobody else should have.
    David1543 wrote: »
    The heavies and officers should have pauldrons and other items as well, each item should differ depending of the legion. Different legions should also have a distinction of color patterns.

    Yes, both Phase I and II clones should have more attachments (with the exception of the Assault class), but they should be universal for each class, not different for each legion. The markings of the Phase I clones are fine though, they just need better attachments.
    David1543 wrote: »
    Officers should look like something of this sort:

    bgpe7jf3t7or.jpg

    That's Wolffe, another clone with a unique look that shouldn't be copied.
    David1543 wrote: »
    The 501st assault deserves better paint jobs, I suggest something like this:

    21slsoa1wkc9.jpg

    That's a Sideshow Collectibles figure that was designed to allow Phase I and Phase II helmets to be interchanged. Despite being released post-TCW, the Phase I look is considered non-canon.
    David1543 wrote: »
    I don't want to use the word "lazy" but the current state of the phase 1 Clones is just disgraceful. They were rushed and no detail were put to them.

    All they're missing are a few attachments, nothing more.
    David1543 wrote: »
    Do you agree they need a few tweaks?

    Yes, but not anywhere near to the same extent as you.

    This, totally.

    Sorry OP, your point is that you have missed the point.

    NEXT!
  • Dude no.

    That is how they just look and its Canon. We cant make it all to satisfy you conpletely.

    The ONLY problem with the Phase 1s is the ugly Heavy with copied incorrect Phase 2 cap. The OG look but without the kama thats the one.

    Make a bloody Phase 1 shiny available! Currently its not...

    Also its a shame the removed some accessories conpletely like Specialist backpack thing. And unnecessarily re-designed some markings for Phase 2 104th for example.
    My priority list:

    1. Fix Split screen mode bugs
    2. Fix bugs
    3. Bigger play area for Duel mode
    4. More love for Starfighter modes
    5. First Person only mode
  • David1543
    536 posts Member
    edited October 17
    @David1543
    cttzedjnn0b21.gif
    David1543 wrote: »
    This is how they look like right now:

    0v7owpzsfkiy.png

    Lame. Nothing but blue or red paint jobs, all the same regardless of class and there's barely a distinction. That's not what the likes of the 501st deserves.

    Because that's what they look like in canon.
    Phase 1 501st
    sng6ru1l80a3.png
    Phase 1 212th
    ubsxob2touwf.png
    Phase 1 327th
    kgdzezhb7pwk.png
    Phase 1 41st
    hskkae0f1zeg.png
    David1543 wrote: »
    We need something like this:

    gi7l06txdisy.png

    We have the one in the middle, the other 2 are non-canon.
    David1543 wrote: »
    u4zjrhge797y.jpg

    That's Fives and Echo, 2 clones with unique and distinctive markings that nobody else should have.
    David1543 wrote: »
    The heavies and officers should have pauldrons and other items as well, each item should differ depending of the legion. Different legions should also have a distinction of color patterns.

    Yes, both Phase I and II clones should have more attachments (with the exception of the Assault class), but they should be universal for each class, not different for each legion. The markings of the Phase I clones are fine though, they just need better attachments.
    David1543 wrote: »
    Officers should look like something of this sort:

    bgpe7jf3t7or.jpg

    That's Wolffe, another clone with a unique look that shouldn't be copied.
    David1543 wrote: »
    The 501st assault deserves better paint jobs, I suggest something like this:

    21slsoa1wkc9.jpg

    That's a Sideshow Collectibles figure that was designed to allow Phase I and Phase II helmets to be interchanged. Despite being released post-TCW, the Phase I look is considered non-canon.
    David1543 wrote: »
    I don't want to use the word "lazy" but the current state of the phase 1 Clones is just disgraceful. They were rushed and no detail were put to them.

    All they're missing are a few attachments, nothing more.
    David1543 wrote: »
    Do you agree they need a few tweaks?

    Yes, but not anywhere near to the same extent as you.

    Dude stop being toxic. I used these pics as examples to show they need more attachments, specially the officer and heavy. I don't care if what I used is Canon or who these clones are. "Thats how they look like in Canon" But phase 1 clone troopers with kamas and pauldrons is also Canon, not all of them had exclusive looks and should be available in game.
    76tzqmmtyls3.png

    If you want changes for phase 1 you're not helping the cause. You're tearing everything down.

  • David1543 wrote: »
    @David1543
    cttzedjnn0b21.gif
    David1543 wrote: »
    This is how they look like right now:

    0v7owpzsfkiy.png

    Lame. Nothing but blue or red paint jobs, all the same regardless of class and there's barely a distinction. That's not what the likes of the 501st deserves.

    Because that's what they look like in canon.
    Phase 1 501st
    sng6ru1l80a3.png
    Phase 1 212th
    ubsxob2touwf.png
    Phase 1 327th
    kgdzezhb7pwk.png
    Phase 1 41st
    hskkae0f1zeg.png
    David1543 wrote: »
    We need something like this:

    gi7l06txdisy.png

    We have the one in the middle, the other 2 are non-canon.
    David1543 wrote: »
    u4zjrhge797y.jpg

    That's Fives and Echo, 2 clones with unique and distinctive markings that nobody else should have.
    David1543 wrote: »
    The heavies and officers should have pauldrons and other items as well, each item should differ depending of the legion. Different legions should also have a distinction of color patterns.

    Yes, both Phase I and II clones should have more attachments (with the exception of the Assault class), but they should be universal for each class, not different for each legion. The markings of the Phase I clones are fine though, they just need better attachments.
    David1543 wrote: »
    Officers should look like something of this sort:

    bgpe7jf3t7or.jpg

    That's Wolffe, another clone with a unique look that shouldn't be copied.
    David1543 wrote: »
    The 501st assault deserves better paint jobs, I suggest something like this:

    21slsoa1wkc9.jpg

    That's a Sideshow Collectibles figure that was designed to allow Phase I and Phase II helmets to be interchanged. Despite being released post-TCW, the Phase I look is considered non-canon.
    David1543 wrote: »
    I don't want to use the word "lazy" but the current state of the phase 1 Clones is just disgraceful. They were rushed and no detail were put to them.

    All they're missing are a few attachments, nothing more.
    David1543 wrote: »
    Do you agree they need a few tweaks?

    Yes, but not anywhere near to the same extent as you.

    If you want changes for phase 1 you're not helping the cause. You're tearing everything down.

    source.gif
    I have always been one of the most vocal people on these forums when it comes to getting clone skins right.
    When DICE announced they were bringing in customisation for the clones, I made this customisation concept of how they could look by setting a specific legion to a specific planet and offering at least 3 additional skins per class. When DICE announced they were planning revamps for the clone skins after they were all added, I made this concept about what those changes should have looked like.
    In both instances, I posted them here on the forums (multiple times), on Reddit, and even tweeted them to the relevant DICE devs to try and get them noticed.
    So don't come at me with this whole "you're not helping the cause" attitude just because I addressed all the things wrong with your assertions when I've put in more work than you ever will to make these skins better, even if those efforts were ultimately fruitless.
    __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    My Concepts
    Clone Skin Changes | Clone Customisation & Menu | Empire Customisation & Menu
  • David1543 wrote: »
    @David1543
    cttzedjnn0b21.gif
    David1543 wrote: »
    This is how they look like right now:

    0v7owpzsfkiy.png

    Lame. Nothing but blue or red paint jobs, all the same regardless of class and there's barely a distinction. That's not what the likes of the 501st deserves.

    Because that's what they look like in canon.
    Phase 1 501st
    sng6ru1l80a3.png
    Phase 1 212th
    ubsxob2touwf.png
    Phase 1 327th
    kgdzezhb7pwk.png
    Phase 1 41st
    hskkae0f1zeg.png
    David1543 wrote: »
    We need something like this:

    gi7l06txdisy.png

    We have the one in the middle, the other 2 are non-canon.
    David1543 wrote: »
    u4zjrhge797y.jpg

    That's Fives and Echo, 2 clones with unique and distinctive markings that nobody else should have.
    David1543 wrote: »
    The heavies and officers should have pauldrons and other items as well, each item should differ depending of the legion. Different legions should also have a distinction of color patterns.

    Yes, both Phase I and II clones should have more attachments (with the exception of the Assault class), but they should be universal for each class, not different for each legion. The markings of the Phase I clones are fine though, they just need better attachments.
    David1543 wrote: »
    Officers should look like something of this sort:

    bgpe7jf3t7or.jpg

    That's Wolffe, another clone with a unique look that shouldn't be copied.
    David1543 wrote: »
    The 501st assault deserves better paint jobs, I suggest something like this:

    21slsoa1wkc9.jpg

    That's a Sideshow Collectibles figure that was designed to allow Phase I and Phase II helmets to be interchanged. Despite being released post-TCW, the Phase I look is considered non-canon.
    David1543 wrote: »
    I don't want to use the word "lazy" but the current state of the phase 1 Clones is just disgraceful. They were rushed and no detail were put to them.

    All they're missing are a few attachments, nothing more.
    David1543 wrote: »
    Do you agree they need a few tweaks?

    Yes, but not anywhere near to the same extent as you.

    Dude stop being toxic. I used these pics as examples to show they need more attachments, specially the officer and heavy. I don't care if what I used is Canon or who these clones are. "Thats how they look like in Canon" But phase 1 clone troopers with kamas and pauldrons is also Canon, not all of them had exclusive looks and should be available in game.
    76tzqmmtyls3.png

    If you want changes for phase 1 you're not helping the cause. You're tearing everything down.

    They were just putting forward a valid argument to counter what you said with some evidence to support it. That's constructive, not toxic.

    Also, only Phase 1 ARC Troopers had kamas and pauldrons in canon.

    Alone against all these droids....? Hmph... they don't stand a chance.
  • David1543 wrote: »
    @David1543
    cttzedjnn0b21.gif
    David1543 wrote: »
    This is how they look like right now:

    0v7owpzsfkiy.png

    Lame. Nothing but blue or red paint jobs, all the same regardless of class and there's barely a distinction. That's not what the likes of the 501st deserves.

    Because that's what they look like in canon.
    Phase 1 501st
    sng6ru1l80a3.png
    Phase 1 212th
    ubsxob2touwf.png
    Phase 1 327th
    kgdzezhb7pwk.png
    Phase 1 41st
    hskkae0f1zeg.png
    David1543 wrote: »
    We need something like this:

    gi7l06txdisy.png

    We have the one in the middle, the other 2 are non-canon.
    David1543 wrote: »
    u4zjrhge797y.jpg

    That's Fives and Echo, 2 clones with unique and distinctive markings that nobody else should have.
    David1543 wrote: »
    The heavies and officers should have pauldrons and other items as well, each item should differ depending of the legion. Different legions should also have a distinction of color patterns.

    Yes, both Phase I and II clones should have more attachments (with the exception of the Assault class), but they should be universal for each class, not different for each legion. The markings of the Phase I clones are fine though, they just need better attachments.
    David1543 wrote: »
    Officers should look like something of this sort:

    bgpe7jf3t7or.jpg

    That's Wolffe, another clone with a unique look that shouldn't be copied.
    David1543 wrote: »
    The 501st assault deserves better paint jobs, I suggest something like this:

    21slsoa1wkc9.jpg

    That's a Sideshow Collectibles figure that was designed to allow Phase I and Phase II helmets to be interchanged. Despite being released post-TCW, the Phase I look is considered non-canon.
    David1543 wrote: »
    I don't want to use the word "lazy" but the current state of the phase 1 Clones is just disgraceful. They were rushed and no detail were put to them.

    All they're missing are a few attachments, nothing more.
    David1543 wrote: »
    Do you agree they need a few tweaks?

    Yes, but not anywhere near to the same extent as you.

    If you want changes for phase 1 you're not helping the cause. You're tearing everything down.

    source.gif
    I have always been one of the most vocal people on these forums when it comes to getting clone skins right.
    When DICE announced they were bringing in customisation for the clones, I made this customisation concept of how they could look by setting a specific legion to a specific planet and offering at least 3 additional skins per class. When DICE announced they were planning revamps for the clone skins after they were all added, I made this concept about what those changes should have looked like.
    In both instances, I posted them here on the forums (multiple times), on Reddit, and even tweeted them to the relevant DICE devs to try and get them noticed.
    So don't come at me with this whole "you're not helping the cause" attitude just because I addressed all the things wrong with your assertions when I've put in more work than you ever will to make these skins better, even if those efforts were ultimately fruitless.

    Your concepts are good. I simply wanted to show they needed more items, and I didn't know what else to use. Thought some would see the point. You came in here with complacency thinking my thread is unworthy just because I didn't handcrafted these images myself.
  • GoodBytes wrote: »
    David1543 wrote: »
    @David1543
    cttzedjnn0b21.gif
    David1543 wrote: »
    This is how they look like right now:

    0v7owpzsfkiy.png

    Lame. Nothing but blue or red paint jobs, all the same regardless of class and there's barely a distinction. That's not what the likes of the 501st deserves.

    Because that's what they look like in canon.
    Phase 1 501st
    sng6ru1l80a3.png
    Phase 1 212th
    ubsxob2touwf.png
    Phase 1 327th
    kgdzezhb7pwk.png
    Phase 1 41st
    hskkae0f1zeg.png
    David1543 wrote: »
    We need something like this:

    gi7l06txdisy.png

    We have the one in the middle, the other 2 are non-canon.
    David1543 wrote: »
    u4zjrhge797y.jpg

    That's Fives and Echo, 2 clones with unique and distinctive markings that nobody else should have.
    David1543 wrote: »
    The heavies and officers should have pauldrons and other items as well, each item should differ depending of the legion. Different legions should also have a distinction of color patterns.

    Yes, both Phase I and II clones should have more attachments (with the exception of the Assault class), but they should be universal for each class, not different for each legion. The markings of the Phase I clones are fine though, they just need better attachments.
    David1543 wrote: »
    Officers should look like something of this sort:

    bgpe7jf3t7or.jpg

    That's Wolffe, another clone with a unique look that shouldn't be copied.
    David1543 wrote: »
    The 501st assault deserves better paint jobs, I suggest something like this:

    21slsoa1wkc9.jpg

    That's a Sideshow Collectibles figure that was designed to allow Phase I and Phase II helmets to be interchanged. Despite being released post-TCW, the Phase I look is considered non-canon.
    David1543 wrote: »
    I don't want to use the word "lazy" but the current state of the phase 1 Clones is just disgraceful. They were rushed and no detail were put to them.

    All they're missing are a few attachments, nothing more.
    David1543 wrote: »
    Do you agree they need a few tweaks?

    Yes, but not anywhere near to the same extent as you.

    Dude stop being toxic. I used these pics as examples to show they need more attachments, specially the officer and heavy. I don't care if what I used is Canon or who these clones are. "Thats how they look like in Canon" But phase 1 clone troopers with kamas and pauldrons is also Canon, not all of them had exclusive looks and should be available in game.
    76tzqmmtyls3.png

    If you want changes for phase 1 you're not helping the cause. You're tearing everything down.

    They were just putting forward a valid argument to counter what you said with some evidence to support it. That's constructive, not toxic.

    Also, only Phase 1 ARC Troopers had kamas and pauldrons in canon.

    Then everyone here is wrong, because Meshugene89 made entire concepts suggesting standard phase1 should have these items I mentioned. I just happened to use the wrong images.
  • My god please no more clone skins. I don't care if they are reworks or new ones...just please no more clone skins
  • bfloo
    15918 posts Member
    David1543 wrote: »
    @David1543
    cttzedjnn0b21.gif
    David1543 wrote: »
    This is how they look like right now:

    0v7owpzsfkiy.png

    Lame. Nothing but blue or red paint jobs, all the same regardless of class and there's barely a distinction. That's not what the likes of the 501st deserves.

    Because that's what they look like in canon.
    Phase 1 501st
    sng6ru1l80a3.png
    Phase 1 212th
    ubsxob2touwf.png
    Phase 1 327th
    kgdzezhb7pwk.png
    Phase 1 41st
    hskkae0f1zeg.png
    David1543 wrote: »
    We need something like this:

    gi7l06txdisy.png

    We have the one in the middle, the other 2 are non-canon.
    David1543 wrote: »
    u4zjrhge797y.jpg

    That's Fives and Echo, 2 clones with unique and distinctive markings that nobody else should have.
    David1543 wrote: »
    The heavies and officers should have pauldrons and other items as well, each item should differ depending of the legion. Different legions should also have a distinction of color patterns.

    Yes, both Phase I and II clones should have more attachments (with the exception of the Assault class), but they should be universal for each class, not different for each legion. The markings of the Phase I clones are fine though, they just need better attachments.
    David1543 wrote: »
    Officers should look like something of this sort:

    bgpe7jf3t7or.jpg

    That's Wolffe, another clone with a unique look that shouldn't be copied.
    David1543 wrote: »
    The 501st assault deserves better paint jobs, I suggest something like this:

    21slsoa1wkc9.jpg

    That's a Sideshow Collectibles figure that was designed to allow Phase I and Phase II helmets to be interchanged. Despite being released post-TCW, the Phase I look is considered non-canon.
    David1543 wrote: »
    I don't want to use the word "lazy" but the current state of the phase 1 Clones is just disgraceful. They were rushed and no detail were put to them.

    All they're missing are a few attachments, nothing more.
    David1543 wrote: »
    Do you agree they need a few tweaks?

    Yes, but not anywhere near to the same extent as you.

    If you want changes for phase 1 you're not helping the cause. You're tearing everything down.

    source.gif
    I have always been one of the most vocal people on these forums when it comes to getting clone skins right.
    When DICE announced they were bringing in customisation for the clones, I made this customisation concept of how they could look by setting a specific legion to a specific planet and offering at least 3 additional skins per class. When DICE announced they were planning revamps for the clone skins after they were all added, I made this concept about what those changes should have looked like.
    In both instances, I posted them here on the forums (multiple times), on Reddit, and even tweeted them to the relevant DICE devs to try and get them noticed.
    So don't come at me with this whole "you're not helping the cause" attitude just because I addressed all the things wrong with your assertions when I've put in more work than you ever will to make these skins better, even if those efforts were ultimately fruitless.

    He really has been, and pointed out flaws no one else would have noticed.
    The Knights of Gareth are Eternal

    Pirate of the Knights of Gareth

    h846398gb27k.png


  • David1543
    536 posts Member
    edited October 17
    My god please no more clone skins. I don't care if they are reworks or new ones...just please no more clone skins

    We cant stop until they get It right. Right now even though It's canon It's not good enough.
  • @meshugene89 Is my thread good now?
Sign In or Register to comment.