criterion-sm dice-lg ea-starwars-lg instagram lucasfilm-lg motive-lg twitch you-tube

Communtiy Transmission- Clone Officer Armor

StarWars0525
2514 posts Member
edited November 2018
Incoming Transmission
With the newly Genosis update arriving soon to battlefront, I would like to bring the topic of clone officer armor to your attention and how I believe there should look like

I decided to take inspiration from the clone wars tv series when choosing how they look. Officers are strong, wise leaders who lead their men into the battlefront so I decided to use the clone captains designs as inspiration for what the armor clone officer should look like.60j314b7tyzx.jpeg

With the wide range of designs, I had no shortage of inspiration to drawn from and made sure that I included a replacement for any and all clone officer legions available from the Star Wars Canon.

212th Attack Battolion- Captain Cody
2toda0x2ez17.png

501st Attack Battolion-Captain Rex
oj1ngopyfpj9.png

327th Star Corps- Captain Bly
op3nia2dvm6b.png

104th Woffle Pack-Captain Woffle
1p2gghro5yev.png

91st Reconnaissance Corps- Commander Neyo
yr9mm3t1n0lb.png

41st Elite Corps- Captain Gree
g4lxevqfutoo.png

Coruscant Guard-Captain Fox
kuucj724za1x.png

Punch It
Post edited by StarWars0525 on

Replies

  • Nice maybe make more Of a generic design rather than each individual commander
  • I like it, plus even though the heavy already uses that style helmet, its still distinguishable by the pistol and lack of backpack. Not that i would care either way, long as i can stop seeing Naval officers in ground battles and taking me out of it
  • Didn't you already post that?
    May your heart be your guiding key.
  • Incoming Transmission
    With the newly Genosis update arriving soon to battlefront, I would like to bring the topic of clone officer armor to your attention and how I believe there should look like

    I decided to take inspiration from the clone wars tv series when choosing how they look. Officers are strong, wise leaders who lead their men into the battlefront so I decided to use the clone captains designs as inspiration for what the armor clone officer should look like.60j314b7tyzx.jpeg

    With the wide range of designs, I had no shortage of inspiration to drawn from and made sure that I included a replacement for any and all clone officer legions available from the Star Wars Canon.

    212th Attack Battolion- Captain Cody
    2toda0x2ez17.png

    501st Attack Battolion-Captain Rex
    oj1ngopyfpj9.png

    327th Star Corps- Captain Bly
    op3nia2dvm6b.png

    104th Woffle Pack-Captain Woffle
    1p2gghro5yev.png

    91st Reconnaissance Corps- Commander Neyo
    yr9mm3t1n0lb.png

    41st Elite Corps- Captain Greer
    3idpzerjm6t5.jpeg

    Coruscant Guard-Captain Fox
    kuucj724za1x.png

    Punch It

    Where is Gree?

  • Incoming Transmission
    With the newly Genosis update arriving soon to battlefront, I would like to bring the topic of clone officer armor to your attention and how I believe there should look like

    I decided to take inspiration from the clone wars tv series when choosing how they look. Officers are strong, wise leaders who lead their men into the battlefront so I decided to use the clone captains designs as inspiration for what the armor clone officer should look like.60j314b7tyzx.jpeg

    With the wide range of designs, I had no shortage of inspiration to drawn from and made sure that I included a replacement for any and all clone officer legions available from the Star Wars Canon.

    212th Attack Battolion- Captain Cody
    2toda0x2ez17.png

    501st Attack Battolion-Captain Rex
    oj1ngopyfpj9.png

    327th Star Corps- Captain Bly
    op3nia2dvm6b.png

    104th Woffle Pack-Captain Woffle
    1p2gghro5yev.png

    91st Reconnaissance Corps- Commander Neyo
    yr9mm3t1n0lb.png

    41st Elite Corps- Captain Greer
    3idpzerjm6t5.jpeg

    Coruscant Guard-Captain Fox
    kuucj724za1x.png

    Punch It

    Where is Gree?

    Edited
  • I have 3 issues with this:
    1 - 5 out of 7 of the officers shown are Commanders, not Captains as they're labeled.
    2 - The officer shown in Gree's place is not Gree himself. Gree is the commander present on Kashyyyhk during Episode III. You have Commander Doom pictured.
    3 - Generic officers should not have these Clone Commanders available as skins. It would be dumb to see 5 Captain Rexs or Commander Codys running around on the field at once.

    While I would love to have armored clone officers in the game, they need to be done right. Otherwise, it would be no better than the Naval Officers we currently have. However, I think Bly's armor is good enough to be used as a template for generic armored officers. To help with class identity (I don't particularly care for this but they seem really big on it), they could remove the Macrobinoculars from the helmet and either replace them with a rangefinder (as seen on Rex's helmet) or they could just have nothing there.
    "In my book, experience outranks everything."
  • Awesome idea. Maybe these characters could correspond with a battallion skin? But then there’d be like 20 Captain Rex’s running around. Hmm...maybe heroes with different skins (Cody, Rex, Keeli, etc)?
  • Nah. Only regular generic armors.
    You guys are gonna make me rich......
    Xbox G-tag
    XJO461
    That Specialist rework was disappointing.
    nceaq2h23fqj.png



  • CPT_Rex wrote: »
    I have 3 issues with this:
    1 - 5 out of 7 of the officers shown are Commanders, not Captains as they're labeled.
    2 - The officer shown in Gree's place is not Gree himself. Gree is the commander present on Kashyyyhk during Episode III. You have Commander Doom pictured.
    3 - Generic officers should not have these Clone Commanders available as skins. It would be dumb to see 5 Captain Rexs or Commander Codys running around on the field at once.

    While I would love to have armored clone officers in the game, they need to be done right. Otherwise, it would be no better than the Naval Officers we currently have. However, I think Bly's armor is good enough to be used as a template for generic armored officers. To help with class identity (I don't particularly care for this but they seem really big on it), they could remove the Macrobinoculars from the helmet and either replace them with a rangefinder (as seen on Rex's helmet) or they could just have nothing there.

    6 out of 7 should be captains, I will check again. Also these aren’t the commanders
    2alysipn6h0u.png

    These are but mabey we should have captains and commanders as reinforcements and arc troopers to replace the officer.
  • CPT_Rex wrote: »
    I have 3 issues with this:
    1 - 5 out of 7 of the officers shown are Commanders, not Captains as they're labeled.
    2 - The officer shown in Gree's place is not Gree himself. Gree is the commander present on Kashyyyhk during Episode III. You have Commander Doom pictured.
    3 - Generic officers should not have these Clone Commanders available as skins. It would be dumb to see 5 Captain Rexs or Commander Codys running around on the field at once.

    While I would love to have armored clone officers in the game, they need to be done right. Otherwise, it would be no better than the Naval Officers we currently have. However, I think Bly's armor is good enough to be used as a template for generic armored officers. To help with class identity (I don't particularly care for this but they seem really big on it), they could remove the Macrobinoculars from the helmet and either replace them with a rangefinder (as seen on Rex's helmet) or they could just have nothing there.

    6 out of 7 should be captains, I will check again. Also these aren’t the commanders
    2alysipn6h0u.png

    These are but mabey we should have captains and commanders as reinforcements and arc troopers to replace the officer.

    No, that’s a Clone Commando, which is an elite group of clones that where usually operationg in the shadows. Clone Commanders, which lead regiments of clones. Commanders also had unique armors signifying their ranks.
    You guys are gonna make me rich......
    Xbox G-tag
    XJO461
    That Specialist rework was disappointing.
    nceaq2h23fqj.png



  • GenxDarchi wrote: »
    CPT_Rex wrote: »
    I have 3 issues with this:
    1 - 5 out of 7 of the officers shown are Commanders, not Captains as they're labeled.
    2 - The officer shown in Gree's place is not Gree himself. Gree is the commander present on Kashyyyhk during Episode III. You have Commander Doom pictured.
    3 - Generic officers should not have these Clone Commanders available as skins. It would be dumb to see 5 Captain Rexs or Commander Codys running around on the field at once.

    While I would love to have armored clone officers in the game, they need to be done right. Otherwise, it would be no better than the Naval Officers we currently have. However, I think Bly's armor is good enough to be used as a template for generic armored officers. To help with class identity (I don't particularly care for this but they seem really big on it), they could remove the Macrobinoculars from the helmet and either replace them with a rangefinder (as seen on Rex's helmet) or they could just have nothing there.

    6 out of 7 should be captains, I will check again. Also these aren’t the commanders
    2alysipn6h0u.png

    These are but mabey we should have captains and commanders as reinforcements and arc troopers to replace the officer.

    No, that’s a Clone Commando, which is an elite group of clones that where usually operationg in the shadows. Clone Commanders, which lead regiments. Commanders also had unique armors signifying their ranks.

    Yeah your right. I get Commanders and Commandos confuse a lot. My bad.
  • GenxDarchi wrote: »
    CPT_Rex wrote: »
    I have 3 issues with this:
    1 - 5 out of 7 of the officers shown are Commanders, not Captains as they're labeled.
    2 - The officer shown in Gree's place is not Gree himself. Gree is the commander present on Kashyyyhk during Episode III. You have Commander Doom pictured.
    3 - Generic officers should not have these Clone Commanders available as skins. It would be dumb to see 5 Captain Rexs or Commander Codys running around on the field at once.

    While I would love to have armored clone officers in the game, they need to be done right. Otherwise, it would be no better than the Naval Officers we currently have. However, I think Bly's armor is good enough to be used as a template for generic armored officers. To help with class identity (I don't particularly care for this but they seem really big on it), they could remove the Macrobinoculars from the helmet and either replace them with a rangefinder (as seen on Rex's helmet) or they could just have nothing there.

    6 out of 7 should be captains, I will check again. Also these aren’t the commanders
    2alysipn6h0u.png

    These are but mabey we should have captains and commanders as reinforcements and arc troopers to replace the officer.

    No, that’s a Clone Commando, which is an elite group of clones that where usually operationg in the shadows. Clone Commanders, which lead regiments. Commanders also had unique armors signifying their ranks.

    Yeah your right. I get Commanders and Commandos confuse a lot. My bad.

    No problem. I can understand how that’s easy to mixup.
    You guys are gonna make me rich......
    Xbox G-tag
    XJO461
    That Specialist rework was disappointing.
    nceaq2h23fqj.png



  • 09lzo0unzy46.jpeg

    This here is a clone captain (officer),
    I wouldn’t mind not having clone Commanders involved clash to much with being a standard trooper and a hero (Crazyness)

    Commados were old republic were they not?

    However i vote big on Arc Troopers for reinforcements for sure, aslong as Droideka were the reinforcement that were apposing them. (My Current Droideka thread fits with this too).
  • I said it on the other thread you posted this on and I'll say it again here: NO!
    These are unique clone Commanders and we're not having multiples of Cody and Rex running around on the battlefield.
    __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    My Concepts
    Clone Skin Changes | Clone Customisation & Menu | Empire Customisation & Menu
  • I said it on the other thread you posted this on and I'll say it again here: NO!
    These are unique clone Commanders and we're not having multiples of Cody and Rex running around on the battlefield.

    You say that as though canon is important at this point.

    Only reason they won’t make it into the game is due to dev resources, not because of concerns that there’s multiple Rex look-a-like Officers.
  • Versatti wrote: »
    I said it on the other thread you posted this on and I'll say it again here: NO!
    These are unique clone Commanders and we're not having multiples of Cody and Rex running around on the battlefield.

    You say that as though canon is important at this point.

    Only reason they won’t make it into the game is due to dev resources, not because of concerns that there’s multiple Rex look-a-like Officers.

    You saying that is very similar to saying you'd be fine having multiple Obi-Wan's running around the map. Rex, Cody and the other Clone Commanders are established, individual characters. So this issue isn't related to canon at all, but having multiple of the same character in the game at once.
    For the EMPIRE!
  • I'm against having established characters armour as skins for a normal grunt officer. I propose (as I have many a time since launch) that the:
    - Assault looks as it currently does (standard armour)
    - Heavy looks like a standard trooper but with the backpack
    - Specialist looks like a standard trooper but with a Kama
    - Officer looks like a standard trooper but with a Pauldron
    This gives each class a 'distinct' look whilst having them as plain as possible in order to allow customization, such as different helmets, bandoliers, reinforced shoulder plates, holsters, etc yet it also allows the Officer to wear armour.
    For the EMPIRE!
  • CPT_Rex wrote: »
    I have 3 issues with this:
    1 - 5 out of 7 of the officers shown are Commanders, not Captains as they're labeled.
    2 - The officer shown in Gree's place is not Gree himself. Gree is the commander present on Kashyyyhk during Episode III. You have Commander Doom pictured.
    3 - Generic officers should not have these Clone Commanders available as skins. It would be dumb to see 5 Captain Rexs or Commander Codys running around on the field at once.

    While I would love to have armored clone officers in the game, they need to be done right. Otherwise, it would be no better than the Naval Officers we currently have. However, I think Bly's armor is good enough to be used as a template for generic armored officers. To help with class identity (I don't particularly care for this but they seem really big on it), they could remove the Macrobinoculars from the helmet and either replace them with a rangefinder (as seen on Rex's helmet) or they could just have nothing there.
    This.

    Clone Officers need armor, but there's no reason to make every Officer look like a unique individual Commander. A pauldron and some unusual markings would do, maybe a kama and/or some extra gear. I like the idea of Clone Officers being relentless to retain distinctiveness.
  • Versatti wrote: »
    I said it on the other thread you posted this on and I'll say it again here: NO!
    These are unique clone Commanders and we're not having multiples of Cody and Rex running around on the battlefield.

    You say that as though canon is important at this point.

    Only reason they won’t make it into the game is due to dev resources, not because of concerns that there’s multiple Rex look-a-like Officers.

    Even DICE aren't silly enough to do as the OP suggests. I'm sure whatever they eventually come up with will be way better than this.
    __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    My Concepts
    Clone Skin Changes | Clone Customisation & Menu | Empire Customisation & Menu
  • Alex64
    6482 posts Member
    Community transmission really? Are you Ben? Geeeez.
  • meshugene89
    3256 posts Member
    edited November 2018
    OK, so, I've done a quick-mock-up of how I feel they could make armoured clone Officers, as well as change the Heavy and Specialist a little bit.
    GEDHXMl.png
    These defaults would, of course, be applied to each legion skin and parts like the pauldron, kama and visor would change colour to match the chosen legion.
    __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    My Concepts
    Clone Skin Changes | Clone Customisation & Menu | Empire Customisation & Menu
  • Inb4 mod changes post title.
  • This is pretty cringe. And also not a good idea. Sorry man. But modeling officers after Clone Commanders is not a good idea for the game.
  • Just give us the yellow ones from the movie and be done with it, none of this cartoon rubbish
  • Just give us the yellow ones from the movie and be done with it, none of this cartoon rubbish

    That "cartoon rubbish", as you call it, is part of Star Wars lore whether you like it or not, and both the suggestion and implementation of content from that show in this game is perfectly reasonable.
    __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    My Concepts
    Clone Skin Changes | Clone Customisation & Menu | Empire Customisation & Menu
  • Raices
    1126 posts Member
    Just give us the yellow ones from the movie and be done with it, none of this cartoon rubbish

    That "cartoon rubbish", as you call it, is part of Star Wars lore whether you like it or not, and both the suggestion and implementation of content from that show in this game is perfectly reasonable.

    Cartoon content is acceptable, but replacing movie content for cartoon exclusive content isn't right.
  • Raices wrote: »
    Just give us the yellow ones from the movie and be done with it, none of this cartoon rubbish

    That "cartoon rubbish", as you call it, is part of Star Wars lore whether you like it or not, and both the suggestion and implementation of content from that show in this game is perfectly reasonable.

    Cartoon content is acceptable, but replacing movie content for cartoon exclusive content isn't right.

    What do you mean by "replace"? Nobody has ever suggested replacing movie content for TV show content, unless you mean people asking for TV show content in favour of movie content.
    __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    My Concepts
    Clone Skin Changes | Clone Customisation & Menu | Empire Customisation & Menu
  • Alex64
    6482 posts Member

    This is the soundtrack when i came down to this place, sorry to say but it's a little bit creepy here.
  • Raices
    1126 posts Member
    Raices wrote: »
    Just give us the yellow ones from the movie and be done with it, none of this cartoon rubbish

    That "cartoon rubbish", as you call it, is part of Star Wars lore whether you like it or not, and both the suggestion and implementation of content from that show in this game is perfectly reasonable.

    Cartoon content is acceptable, but replacing movie content for cartoon exclusive content isn't right.

    What do you mean by "replace"? Nobody has ever suggested replacing movie content for TV show content, unless you mean people asking for TV show content in favour of movie content.
    Yeah, this
  • Raices wrote: »
    Raices wrote: »
    Just give us the yellow ones from the movie and be done with it, none of this cartoon rubbish

    That "cartoon rubbish", as you call it, is part of Star Wars lore whether you like it or not, and both the suggestion and implementation of content from that show in this game is perfectly reasonable.

    Cartoon content is acceptable, but replacing movie content for cartoon exclusive content isn't right.

    What do you mean by "replace"? Nobody has ever suggested replacing movie content for TV show content, unless you mean people asking for TV show content in favour of movie content.
    Yeah, this

    Well, again to be fair, there is some pretty good content from the TV shows (CW and Rebels) like heroes (Ahsoka, Ventress, Ezra, Grand Inquisitor), planets (Christophsis, Ryloth (ground battles), Mandalore, Lothal, Atollon), as well as skins, possible new reinforcements, and also vehicles. However, I do believe that movie content should come first and we still have plenty of movie content from the PT and OT to include in this game: Felucia, Mygeeto, Bespin (large map), Jedha, Scarif, Padme, Jango, Nien Nunb, Dengar, Jyn, Krennic, Airborne Troopers, Recon Troopers, Clone Scout Troopers, Crab Droids, Magnaguards, Droidekas, Shoretroopers, etc.
    __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    My Concepts
    Clone Skin Changes | Clone Customisation & Menu | Empire Customisation & Menu
  • Raices wrote: »
    Raices wrote: »
    Just give us the yellow ones from the movie and be done with it, none of this cartoon rubbish

    That "cartoon rubbish", as you call it, is part of Star Wars lore whether you like it or not, and both the suggestion and implementation of content from that show in this game is perfectly reasonable.

    Cartoon content is acceptable, but replacing movie content for cartoon exclusive content isn't right.

    What do you mean by "replace"? Nobody has ever suggested replacing movie content for TV show content, unless you mean people asking for TV show content in favour of movie content.
    Yeah, this

    Well, again to be fair, there is some pretty good content from the TV shows (CW and Rebels) like heroes (Ahsoka, Ventress, Ezra, Grand Inquisitor), planets (Christophsis, Ryloth (ground battles), Mandalore, Lothal, Atollon), as well as skins, possible new reinforcements, and also vehicles. However, I do believe that movie content should come first and we still have plenty of movie content from the PT and OT to include in this game: Felucia, Mygeeto, Bespin (large map), Jedha, Scarif, Padme, Jango, Nien Nunb, Dengar, Jyn, Krennic, Airborne Troopers, Recon Troopers, Clone Scout Troopers, Crab Droids, Magnaguards, Droidekas, Shoretroopers, etc.

    Why I believe that CW should be held in the same regard as the movies and not disregarded in favour of the films in terms of bringing in content, but not Rebels or Resistance, is because it follows on from the films and directly ties into them, with the show including the main characters that are the mains for the films as well, whilst Rebels and Resistance follow their own story with a new cast, being only loosely connected to the films via cameos from characters that are in the films.
    For the EMPIRE!
  • IIPrest0nII
    4116 posts SWBF Senior Moderator
    Thread closed due to misleading title. If you have suggestions for the game, please post in the correct section: https://battlefront-forums.ea.com/categories/bfII-feedback
    SWBF Forums Senior Moderator/ Check out the forum rules & guidelines
This discussion has been closed.

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!